Fine mess: Supreme Court justices split on whether agencies can hit firms with penalties
The Supreme Court seemed divided Tuesday in a case that could weaken many federal agencies' power to fine businesses that break the law. Sun Valley Orchards, accused of violations under the temporary farmworker visa program, argues the Labor Department's administrative fines are unconstitutional and deny a jury trial. Deputy Solicitor General Harris warned that requiring courts to impose all civil penalties would be "catastrophic" and lead to under-enforcement. Chief Justice Roberts strongly suggested administrations have exceeded executive power, while Alito and Kagan traded quips over a possible mixed ruling.
Why it matters: The ruling could limit federal agencies' power to fine businesses without a court trial, affecting how labor and other laws are enforced, and whether companies can demand juries before paying penalties.
Comments
No comments yet.